Media Critique Assignment: Analyze the Reaction to the New ‘Star Wars’ Slate and What It Teaches About Fan Studies

Hook: Turn fandom noise into a learning lab

Students and teachers often hit the same roadblocks when studying media: scattered, low-quality reactions online; strong emotions that cloud analysis; and few clear methods for turning viral debate into credit-bearing work. The January 2026 announcement that Kathleen Kennedy had stepped down and Dave Filoni would co-lead Lucasfilm — alongside a newly revealed Filoni-era movie slate — created a perfect real-time case study. Social feeds lit up with praise, skepticism, nostalgia, and critique. That moment is a classroom goldmine for teaching fan studies, franchise stewardship, and practical media critique.

Why this moment matters (2026 context)

By early 2026 the media landscape shows two clear trends: franchises are consolidating creative leadership around trusted creators, and audiences are increasingly segmented across platforms. Lucasfilm’s leadership shift and the new Filoni-era slate embody both. The reaction was shaped not just by the titles announced but by broader cultural dynamics in late 2025 — streaming fatigue, nostalgia-driven IP strategies, and an appetite for creator-driven continuity after a decade of mixed franchise stewardship.

Key teaching opportunities

• Fan studies in practice: Observe who speaks for fandom, whose voices are amplified, and how community norms shape discourse.
• Expectations management: Study how announcements, leaks, and leadership changes recalibrate expectations and brand trust.
• Franchise stewardship: Analyze how decision-making (e.g., prioritizing continuity, creator authority) affects audience reception and long-term IP health.

Course module overview: Media Critique Assignment (4 weeks)

This assignment converts the media reaction to the Filoni-era movie list into a structured research project. It works for undergraduate media studies, communications, and secondary AP seminar classes. The module is scaffolded: collection, categorization, analysis, critique, and reflection.

Learning objectives

• Apply qualitative and quantitative methods to analyze fan reaction across platforms.
• Differentiate between critique, commentary, and coordinated messaging.
• Evaluate the role of franchise leadership in shaping public expectations.
• Produce an evidence-based media critique and public-facing brief for franchise stakeholders.

Week-by-week breakdown

1. Week 1 — Collection: Students gather reaction data (tweets/X posts, Reddit threads, TikTok videos, YouTube comment clusters, fanforum threads) from the 72-hour window around the announcement. Emphasize ethical scraping and Terms of Service awareness. Provide sample search strings and filters (e.g., "Filoni slate", "Mandalorian and Grogu", "Kathleen Kennedy steps down").
2. Week 2 — Categorization & coding: Use open coding to identify themes: excitement, nostalgia, skepticism, franchise fatigue, creator worship, gatekeeping. Teach inter-coder reliability (Cohen’s kappa) with a short exercise.
3. Week 3 — Analysis: Combine sentiment analysis (basic lexicon approach or off-the-shelf tools) with qualitative discourse analysis. Map influential nodes using simple network tools (NodeXL, Gephi) and run Google Trends comparisons to show attention spikes.
4. Week 4 — Critique & stewardship brief: Students write a 1,200–1,500 word media critique that synthesizes findings and issues a one-page stewardship brief for Lucasfilm (or imagined franchise leadership) with concrete recommendations.

Practical tools and ethics (2026-friendly)

In-class work should balance sophistication with accessibility. By 2026, some APIs (notably for X) are gated or costly; design assignments with flexible data sources.

Low-barrier tools

• Manual collection: screenshots, saved HTML, and archive.org snapshots.
• Google Trends and YouTube analytics for attention metrics.
• Spreadsheet coding (Google Sheets) for hand-coded categories.
• Free visualization: Gephi (network graphs) and RAWGraphs for charts.

Advanced options (for research-focused classes)

• Python (pandas, scikit-learn) for topic modeling (LDA) and sentiment baselines.
• NVivo or Atlas.ti for qualitative coding and memoing.
• Brandwatch / Talkwalker for paid social listening (if institutional access exists).

Ethics & platform policy

Teach students to respect user privacy: avoid republishing private DMs, anonymize handles, and follow each platform’s Terms of Service. If using scraped datasets, get instructor approval and document methods. Discuss the ethics of quoting fans and the risk of doxxing, harassment, and algorithmic amplification of harmful narratives.

Assignment deliverables and rubric

Clear grading criteria keep analysis focused and teachable. Below is a recommended rubric instructors can adapt.

Deliverables

1. Dataset package (collected artifacts + README) — 20%
2. Coding scheme and inter-coder reliability report — 15%
3. Analysis visualizations (network map, sentiment chart, theme word cloud) — 20%
4. Media critique essay (1,200–1,500 words) — 30%
5. One-page stewardship brief for franchise leadership — 15%

Sample rubric (high-level)

• A (90–100): Robust dataset, transparent methods, strong triangulation between quantitative and qualitative evidence, actionable stewardship recommendations grounded in data and scholarship.
• B (80–89): Solid methods and clear results; some gaps in triangulation or weaker stewardship guidance.
• C (70–79): Basic collection and description with limited analysis; recommendations are speculative.
• D/F: Poor documentation, weak or missing analysis, or ethical violations in data collection.

Teaching tips: scaffolding complex concepts

Many students conflate fandom with a monolithic public. Use short mini-lessons to unpack that fallacy.

Micro-lessons to include

• Fandom heterogeneity: Explain differences between participatory fans (fan creators), consumer fans (casual viewers), and gatekeepers (moderators, influencers).
• Noise vs. signal: Show how highly active users can skew impressions; introduce sampling techniques to avoid over-weighting superusers.
• Franchise stewardship principles: Define stewardship as a long-term strategy balancing continuity, innovation, and audience trust.

Example findings students often surface

Here are typical patterns instructors should expect. These show how the Filoni-era announcement can teach analytical skills, not just fandom critique.

• Polarized initial sentiment: A mix of nostalgic enthusiasm from viewers attached to animated continuity and skepticism from those worried about "fan service" or franchise overreach.
• Influencer-driven narratives: A handful of creators with large followings often reframe the announcement (positive or negative) and drive mainstream media coverage.
• Platform-specific discourse: TikTok tends to prioritize video reaction and trendable moments; Reddit fosters long-form debate; X (formerly Twitter) amplifies hot takes and counter-takes.
• Temporal dynamics: Immediate outrage or praise often normalizes after 48–72 hours as context and official details emerge.

Sample student critique outline (model answer)

Use this outline as a template you can grade against.

1. Introduction: Contextualize Kennedy’s departure and the Filoni-era slate (50–100 words).
2. Methods: Describe dataset, coding, and analytic tools (100–150 words).
3. Findings: Present three main themes with evidence (400–500 words).
4. Discussion: Interpret what this reveals about fan power, expectations, and franchise stewardship (300–350 words).
5. Stewardship recommendations: Three concrete, prioritized actions for Lucasfilm leadership (150–200 words).

Example stewardship recommendations

• Publish a transparent roadmap that clarifies continuity and creative milestones to reduce rumor-driven anxiety.
• Establish ongoing community liaison roles to surface fan concerns and creative feedback without ceding creative control.
• Balance legacy nostalgia with fresh narratives: commit one project per slate to experimental storytelling to prevent stagnation.

Advanced strategies and 2026 predictions

As franchises navigate creator-led stewardship in 2026, the classroom project offers insights into future moves.

What to watch next

• Creator-presidency models: More studios will install creatives into leadership roles, but success hinges on data-driven stewardship and transparent stakeholder communication.
• Algorithmic fandom: AI-curated feeds will accelerate niche fandoms while increasing echo chambers — teaching students to detect algorithmic bias will be essential.
• Hybrid release strategies: Franchises will lean into staggered cross-platform storytelling (films, shorts, interactive experiences) to retain multi-generational audiences.

Classroom-forward predictions

Expect media reaction analysis to become standard in media curricula. The best programs will pair computational tools with ethnographic methods so students can move beyond surface sentiment into structural understanding.

Common pitfalls and how to avoid them

• Overgeneralizing fandom: Avoid treating sampled comments as universal truth — always qualify scope and limits.
• Relying on one platform: Triangulate across platforms for a fuller picture.
• Neglecting ethics: Make anonymization and consent core grading criteria.

“The new Filoni-era list of 'Star Wars' movies does not sound great,” observed some early coverage — but the claim gains weight or fades depending on how we measure and contextualize reaction.

Actionable takeaways for instructors and students

• Start with a clear research question (e.g., How did fans respond to leadership change vs. project slate?).
• Limit the sampling window to make projects manageable — 72 hours around the announcement is effective.
• Prioritize transparent methods: require a README file for datasets and a log of decisions.
• Use mixed methods: combine a small-scale lexicon sentiment score with three qualitative exemplar threads to add nuance.
• Make stewardship recommendations practical and prioritized — one short-term, one medium-term, one long-term action.

Final reflection: what this assignment teaches about power and care

Study of the Filoni-era slate reaction is more than fandom gossip. It shows how leadership changes, announcement framing, and platform ecosystems produce public meaning. Students learn that critique should be evidence-based, that fan communities are diverse and powerful, and that effective franchise stewardship requires both creative vision and community engagement.

Call-to-action

Ready to run this project in your classroom? Download the editable assignment pack (rubric, dataset template, and slide deck) and join our educator forum to share outcomes. Test the assignment, adapt it, and contribute a student example to our growing repository — turn noisy fandom moments into rigorous learning experiences. For course delivery and hosting, consider the top platforms for selling online courses and build student portfolios with hands-on portfolio projects that include AI video work.

Related Reading

• Digital Footprint & Live-Streaming: Should Students Add Twitch/Bluesky Activity to Portfolios?
• Field Kits & Edge Tools for Modern Newsrooms (2026)
• Future Predictions: Monetization, Moderation and the Messaging Product Stack (2026–2028)
• When Platform Drama Drives Installs: A Publisher’s Playbook for Community Migration
• Stress-Test Your Brand: Navigating Audience Backlash During Franchise Changes
• From Viral Meme to Fan Chants: How 'Very Chinese Time' Shows the Power of Cultural Moments in Cricket Fandom
• Rising Prices, Shrinking Care: How 2026 Inflation Could Affect Access to Chronic Disease Management
• Convenience-Store Cleansers: Are Travel-Size Washes at Asda Express Worth the Buy?
• An Educator’s Guide to Choosing the Right CRM for Student Outreach
• How to Issue Time-Limited Emergency Credentials for Activists Using Intermittent Satellite Internet